Gettysburg is a town built on remembering things, but its wing game is very much in the present tense. You can start at the Blue & Gray, where the char is proper and the regulars will size you up, then pivot to Tommy's, where a sweet, sticky glaze has been doing the same thing for five decades.

It's a spread that runs from a candlelit tavern older than electricity to a late-night shack frying Oreos for the post-bar crowd, and I ate at all of them. The best part is the local honesty: even the crepe place will point you down the street.

So go get your fingers dirty. The list is below.

Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Highlights
Best wings in town
Super friendly staff
Great beer and cocktails
Cozy local hangout
Easy Lincoln Square access

I started at the Blue & Gray, because if you're going to claim best wings in town, you should be willing to defend that title in the opening round. The place was busy, but the staff waved me to a stool with the casual authority of people who have seen every kind of hungry tourist. I ordered the wings, naturally, and a local ale. The wings arrived with a proper amount of char and a sauce that clung like it meant business. Not fancy. Just right. The crowd was a comfortable mix of regulars and folks like me, all of us happy to be out of the rain. Easy walk from the square. I could see coming back here.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Frederick.

Gloryridge Tavern and Grill

Highlights
Excellent steak and shrimp
Quiet, calm dining room
Attentive service from Jill
Tasty, juicy burgers
Memorable casual dinner

Gloryridge Tavern is the kind of place you find when you're not looking, which is perhaps the only way to find it. The dining room was quiet, almost library-like, save for the gentle clatter of silverware. Jill, my server, appeared at precisely the moments I needed something, which is a rare talent. I had the steak and shrimp, because the menu had a confidence about it, and the steak came as ordered, the shrimp plump and sweet. But I was here for wings, and they held their own, crisp-edged and tossed in a buttery heat. The burger across the table looked excellent too. I left impressed, if not converted.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Hagerstown.

Appalachian Brewing Company of Gettysburg - Battlefield

Highlights
Great beer brats
Fantastic pierogies
Excellent Boo Boo Burger
Attentive, friendly service
Affordable souvenir glasses

Appalachian Brewing Company sits near the battlefield, which means you can pair your wings with a history lesson, or just pair them with a pint of something hoppy. The beer brats were excellent, and the pierogies were a pleasant distraction, but the wings were the real story. They were meaty, properly sauced, and served with a quiet competence. The Boo Boo Burger, named for something I didn't ask about, also earned its reputation. Service was friendly without being overbearing, and I nearly bought a souvenir glass for the novelty of it. In the end, I walked out with a full stomach and a mild regret about not buying the glass.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Frederick.

Dobbin House Tavern

Highlights
Historic atmosphere, ample parking
Quick seating despite early arrival
Outstanding food, friendly service
Delicious daily specials
Quaint, charming old tavern

The Dobbin House is old enough to have opinions, and it does, but it's gracious about it. I arrived early, which I recommend, because the parking lot fills fast and the dining room is small, old, and full of charm. The host seated me quickly, and the daily specials were recited with the kind of pride that suggests they change often and well. I ordered wings, because that's the assignment, and they came out hot, with a smoky depth that felt appropriate for a building that predates electricity. The service was friendly, almost familial. The atmosphere alone would bring me back, but the food made it a certainty.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Germantown.

Michaux Brewing Company - Gettysburg

Highlights
Right off downtown circle
Friendly staff, excellent service
Solid bar food, daily specials
Great local beer variety
Comfortable, low-key atmosphere

Michaux Brewing is right off the circle, which means you can stumble in after a day of ghost tours and cannon photography. The staff greeted me like a regular, even though I clearly wasn't, and the beer list had enough variety to make choosing difficult. I ordered wings and a pale ale, and the wings were solid, bar-food honest, with a decent char and a sauce that didn't apologize. The specials board was tempting, and I overheard someone praising the pretzel. The room is low-key, comfortable, and mercifully free of faux-colonial decor. I'll be back, probably sooner than later, and I'll bring friends.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Ellicott City.

The Upper Crust

Highlights
Great prices for quality
Service starts fast
Good for large groups
Outdoor seating available
Worth recommending

The Upper Crust is the sort of place that doesn't need to try too hard, because the prices are fair and the food arrives before you've finished your first glass of water. I ordered wings, and they came out quickly, crisp and sauced without being drowned. The service was efficient, and the room handled a large group of what looked like a church outing with aplomb. There's outdoor seating, which I didn't use because it was February, but I appreciate the option. For the price, this place is hard to beat. I'd recommend it to anyone passing through, and I mean that sincerely, not as filler.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Herndon.

Tommy's Pizza

Highlights
Five decades of consistency
Sweet sauce that works
Old-school authentic subs
Kid-approved pepperoni pizza

Tommy's Pizza has been doing this for five decades, and you can taste the consistency. The sweet sauce on the wings is unusual, but it works, coating each piece in a sticky, slightly tangy glaze that makes you want another bite before you've swallowed the first. The subs are old-school, which means they taste like they were made by someone who has seen enough trends come and go. The pepperoni pizza was approved by a nearby child, which is the highest compliment. I didn't stay long, but I left with the sense that Tommy's knows exactly what it is and has no interest in being anything else. There's a quiet dignity in that.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Leesburg.

Cottage Creperie

Highlights
Friendly, bustling small spot
Quick, tasty sweet crepes
Helpful staff, local tips
Coffee worth the visit

Cottage Creperie is a small, bustling spot that feels like it's always about to run out of room, but enjoys the chaos. I popped in for a sweet crepe, which was quick and tasty, and the coffee was strong enough to justify the visit on its own. The staff were helpful, offering local tips with the ease of people who love their town. I didn't have wings here, because crepes are not wings, but I asked, and they laughed and pointed me down the street. If you're in the mood for something delicate and sweet, this is your place. Just don't come hungry for poultry.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Gettysburg.

Mai Noodle House

Highlights
Fresh sushi, fair prices
Graceful service under pressure
Red interior, subtle art
Beef soup had gristle
Worth planning a return

Mai Noodle House is easy to miss, which is a shame, because the red interior and subtle art make it a nice place to sit and recover from a day of walking. I ordered the beef soup, which had some gristle, and the sushi, which was fresh and fairly priced. The service was graceful, even when the room got busy, and I never felt rushed. I didn't have wings here, because this is not a wing place, but I did ask, and they gave me a polite no. That honesty is worth something. I'll be back for the sushi, and I'll plan my order more carefully next time, perhaps the dumplings.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Columbia.

Gettysburg Family Restaurant

Highlights
Fresh mozzarella sticks
Tender sandwiches, perfect gravy
Impeccable table service
Slab of chocolate cake
Two meals, thirty dollars

Gettysburg Family Restaurant is exactly what it sounds like, and that's a compliment. The mozzarella sticks were fresh, not the frozen kind, and the sandwiches came tender with a gravy that I could have drunk. The table service was impeccable, the kind of attentive that makes you feel looked after without being hovered over. I had the chocolate cake, which was a slab, not a slice, and I finished it because I am a professional. Two meals, a dessert, and a glass of tea cost me thirty dollars, which feels like a bargain in this economy. The wings, when I ordered them on a previous visit, were solid, no nonsense. This place is a reliable stop.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Leesburg.

Hunterstown Diner

Highlights
Huge portions, fair prices
Ribs fall-off-the-bone tender
Steak cooked perfectly medium rare
Warm, welcoming small-town atmosphere
Attentive, friendly service throughout

Hunterstown Diner is a bit out of town, but worth the drive, especially if you're hungry. The portions are enormous, and the prices are fair enough that I felt guilty leaving half a plate of ribs. The ribs fell off the bone, which is a cliché, but true here. I ordered the steak medium rare, and it came out exactly that, which never happens. The wings were an afterthought, but they held their own, crunchy and hot. The service was attentive, and the room had that small-town warmth that makes you want to stay for coffee and pie. I'll be back, and I'll bring a bigger appetite.

You might also want to check out the best antique store in Frederick.

Cj's Takeout and Late Nite Bites

Highlights
Best late-night snack shack
Deep-fried deviled eggs stand out
Great late-night food spot
Delicious mozz sticks and Oreos
Phenomenal dip sauce pairing

CJ's Takeout and Late Nite Bites is the kind of place that exists for the after-hours crowd, but I went at seven because I have standards. The deep-fried deviled eggs are a revelation, creamy and crispy, and the mozzarella sticks were properly stringy. The Oreos, battered and fried, were a sweet finish that I didn't know I needed. The wings, which are the real reason I was there, came out hot and saucy, with a dip sauce that paired so well I asked for extra. This is the best late-night snack shack in town, and possibly the only one. If you find yourself hungry after dark, this is where you go.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Germantown.